Runs Scored (season)
67 – John Sluka (1961)

Stolen Bases (season)
57 – John Sluka (1961)

Stolen Bases (career)
114 – John Sluka (1961)

Consecutive Wins (season)
31 – Doug Vanderwall (1959-61)
19 – Roger Wheeler (1960-61)

Wins (career)
33 – Doug Vanderwall (1959-61)

ERA (career)
1.10 – Roger Wheeler (191 innings) (1959-61)
1.19 – Doug Vanderwall (218 innings) (1959-61)

Strikeouts (game – extra inings)
21 – Doug Vanderwall vs. Traverse City (8 inn.) (1961)

Strikeouts (career)
369 – Doug Vanderwall, Grand Haven (1959-61)

Consecutive Wins
56 – (4/19/1960 – 4/17/1962)

Stolen Bases (Season)
165 – (1961)

MHSAA Baseball Records